A Little Perspective, Please
As most of you probably know by now, the Supreme Court has ruled that the federal ban on D&X (partial-birth) abortion is constitutional. The question is: just how significant is this victory for the overall effort to protect the unborn?
From a psychological standpoint, this is clearly an enormous shot in the arm for the pro-life movement. To fully appreciate the significance of this ruling, all you have to do is imagine what the effect would have been on our people had it gone the other way. The fact is, after years of being pummeled in the courts this decision puts a little wind back in our sails.
Equally important, it appears to have truly demoralized our enemies. Some are wringing their ice-cold little hands and wailing that the end of legalized abortion is near. Apparently, the prospect of living in a world in which moms are not allowed to butcher their children by the millions has caused a large percentage of these people to start sleeping with the lights on.
Meanwhile, more optimistic members of the Choice Mafia are threatening to turn this ruling into a rallying cry to re-energize their troops. Only time will tell whether they are able to do this or not. My prediction is that this ruling will not energize anyone other than the most rabid abortion enthusiasts and their numbers are so small as to be inconsequential. But however it plays out, this decision is further proof that the pro-life side has the momentum and our enemies know it.
Beyond its positive psychological impact, the ban on partial-birth abortion is meaningless as it relates to the actual killing of unborn children. That’s because this ban controls the how, not the whether. Remember, even during the time that this procedure was allowed, most late-term abortions were accomplished using other methods – the most common being D&E. Unfortunately, D&E and all of these other procedures are still legal which means that any baby who would have been killed by partial-birth abortion before will now be killed by one of these other methods.
Some pro-lifers argue that the practical benefit of a ban on partial-birth abortion is that it prohibits a procedure that is especially barbaric. Such people are poorly informed. Be assured, anyone who thinks that a D&E is less brutal for the child being killed than a D&X knows nothing about abortion procedures.
In the final analysis, the psychological importance of this victory for the pro-life movement is enormous but its practical implications for the unborn are zero. The real unknown is whether this Supreme Court ruling is a barometer for abortion rulings to come.
Many observers have noted that there was some encouraging language in the majority opinion to indicate a willingness by the Court to reconsider Roe vs. Wade. Others counter that it was a 5-4 decision in which one vote (Kennedy’s) cannot be relied upon in the future. In my view, each conclusion is equally valid and equally irrelevant.
I will say this as succinctly as I can. Trying to predict what the United States Supreme Court will or will not do is a fool’s game. The reality is, when the Court abandoned the Constitution as the basis for its rulings – which it did years ago – by definition it became totally unpredictable. Today, if there is one thing we know for certain about Supreme Court decisions it is that anyone with a Ouija Board can predict them as accurately as the most educated legal minds in the country.
So my advice is (a) pause for a moment to celebrate the victory, (b) don’t read more into it than is actually there, and (c) get back to work.
Babies are still dying.

